Battle of the Best: 5 Popular Long Wear Setting Sprays Put to the Smudge Test
- Mia Anderson
- Jun 26
- 4 min read
Updated: Jun 27
When it comes to long-wear makeup, a great setting spray can make or break your look. Whether you're headed to a full-day event or dancing the night away, you need a setting spray that truly locks everything in place. But with so many options out there, which one actually lives up to the hype ?
I put five of the most popular long-lasting setting sprays to the ultimate smudge test and the results might surprise you. Here’s how each spray held up, what makes a good long-wear formula, and how to use it properly for best results.
What Makes a Great Long-Wear Setting Spray?
Not all setting sprays are created equal. If you want your makeup to stay flawless from morning to night, look for a setting spray that:
Contains Film-Forming Agents – These ingredients create a thin, flexible barrier that locks in makeup and resists transfer.
Is Alcohol-Based (if suitable for your skin) – While not ideal for dry or sensitive skin, alcohol-based sprays dry down quickly and grip makeup for extended wear.
Dries Matte or Natural, Not Sticky – Long-wear sprays should leave your skin feeling weightless and not tacky after application.
Is Sweat, Humidity & Transfer-Resistant – Check if it's tested for conditions like heat or movement to ensure it really lasts.
Works With Your Skin Type – Oily skin benefits from mattifying formulas, while dry skin may need hydrating long-wear sprays.
How to Use Setting Spray the Right Way
To get the best results from your setting spray, follow these simple steps:
Shake the Bottle – This ensures all ingredients are evenly mixed for consistent application.
Apply After All Makeup – Mist your face as the final step in your routine — after foundation, concealer, blush, etc.
Spray in an X and T Pattern – Hold the bottle 8–10 inches away and spritz in an “X” followed by a “T” to evenly coat the face.
Let It Dry Naturally – Don’t fan it in or touch your face right away. Give it a few seconds to set.
Use Between Layers (Optional) – For serious longevity, lightly mist between foundation and powder layers.
Pro Tip: Want even more grip? Spray your beauty sponge with setting spray and press it into the skin for a long-wear finish.
The Smudge Test: 5 Sprays Reviewed
1. Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray
Let’s just say — this one did not disappoint. After saturating the product on the skin and letting it dry completely, I gave it the ol’ smudge test. It held up beautifully.
Smudge Score: 9.5/10
This spray is one of my personal favorites for a reason. It creates a smooth, slightly tacky base that truly helps makeup cling without breaking down. A top contender for oily or combo skin types!
2. MAC Fix + Stay Over
I had high hopes for this one because of MAC’s long-standing rep in the makeup world. But in the smudge test, it just didn’t hold its ground.
Smudge Score: 5/10
It didn’t take much effort to disturb the product — which is a letdown for something that’s marketed as long-wearing. Better for light makeup days or hydrating touch-ups rather than full glam.
3. Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray
This cult-favorite setting spray didn’t come to play. Even with fewer sprays, it packed serious staying power and passed the smudge test with flying colors.
Smudge Score: 10/10
It lived up to its iconic status. If you want your makeup to last all night (literally), this is your go-to. Great for all skin types and high-humidity situations.
4. Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Set + Refresh Spray
I’ve always loved Milk’s Hydro Grip primer, so I was curious about how the setting spray would perform. It wasn’t the strongest of the bunch but still held up decently.
Smudge Score: 8/10
This one’s great for hydrating the skin and creating a soft-set finish. It’s ideal if you prefer a dewy look or have dry to normal skin. Not bulletproof, but still reliable for everyday wear.
5. ONE/SIZE Until Dawn Mattifying Waterproof Setting Spray
This is one of my personal ride-or-dies when it comes to setting sprays. But to my surprise, during the smudge test it didn’t perform as well as I expected — at least on bare product.
Smudge Score: 8/10
Though it didn’t wow me in this specific test, I’ve used it over full base makeup before and it’s nearly indestructible. So I’ll give it the benefit of the doubt — this one shines when layered over foundation or concealer.
Final Thoughts: Which Setting Spray Reigns Supreme?
Top Picks:
Urban Decay All Nighter – The undefeated champion of long-lasting wear.
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless – A close second for its smooth hold and finish.
Best for Hydration: Milk Hydro Grip
Best for Natural Finish: MAC Fix+ (but maybe not your first choice for longevity)
Best for Full Glam Looks: ONE/SIZE Until Dawn (on top of a full face!)
Why Setting Spray Matters
Setting spray isn't just a finishing step — it's your secret weapon for makeup that lasts. It:
Locks in your look
Reduces creasing and oil breakthrough
Blurs texture
Keeps products in place through sweat, humidity, and long wear
Choosing the right one for your skin type and makeup goals can make a huge difference. So next time you’re prepping your glam, don’t forget to mist!
Have you tried any of these setting sprays? Which one’s your holy grail? Let me know in the comments below !
Comments